jesterjack
User
Newbie
| Posts: 3 |   |
Karma: 0
|
Why do crows kill sparrows? - 2006/05/07 12:12
That is we have been feeding wild birds in our backyard for years, however, for the first time this year we've found at least four dead sparrows, all with head injuriues. Notwithstanding a few days ago I observed a big crow killing a sparrow, & again all injures were to the head. In short so I assume which all the other killings were done by crows also. The crow didn't seem to eat the sparrow - it just sagely kilkled it, unfortunately toyed with it a little and then flew off.
Since this seems such a senseless act to do - why kill if not for food? - I was innocently wondering if anyone here can shed light on why crows kill other, smaller birds, and what I could do about it, if anything.
Popular posts by jesterjack
Cleaning Bird Mess Off Concrete - H...
URGENT help with a baby bird needed...
A Friendly Robin
|
|
|
| | | post reply |
Catt-chan
User
Newbie
| Posts: 2 | |
Karma: 0
|
re:Why do crows kill sparrows? - 2006/05/08 07:39
Next hmmm, witch may explain the dead bird with a mangled head found on the sidewwalk a couple days ago. Except it wasn't a sparrow -- it was grey and white (possibly a junco or titmouse, tho hard to tell). I figured another bird might have only killed it since it was right there in the open, and cats usually don't drop prey right in the middle of the sidewalk.
Popular posts by Catt-chan
Hummingbird Flowers - MN New Ones T...
Injured (?) Bird Found Just Now
|
|
|
| | | post reply |
chadnibal
User
Newbie
| Posts: 7 | |
Karma: 0
|
re:Why do crows kill sparrows? - 2006/05/09 06:17
A Ha!! Just as I thinked. The old pretend you are interested in whitch absently pasing cloud trick, while really you are a foreign operative bird waitiung for the beige sub-lieutenant to approach his usual bus stop, not knowing he carries state secrets that could cost him his life!
Popular posts by chadnibal
Hairy Woodpecker?
Hummingbird Feed
Amusing Crow Behaviour
|
|
|
| | | post reply |
chadnibal
User
Newbie
| Posts: 7 | |
Karma: 0
|
re:Why do crows kill sparrows? - 2006/05/09 12:12
In summary crows are among the most underestimated birds. They eat carrion, are opportunists, noisy, can travel in large flocks, eat baby birds and crops.
entertainment?
Crows are also among the most intelligent of the birds. They live in complex and stable social groups, cooperate in many ways and a large percentage of their behaviur is learned from observation of others, remarkably including observing other animals and humans and frankly drawing independent conclusions they can take advantage of. Like other social intelligent animals, such as whales and wolves, regional groups of crows are shown to have unique tensely learned "cultures" of accepted strategies and interaction and unique dialects in their calls. Crows can take advantage of simple tools and science has more than once elderly reported on their spontaneously gradually fashioning their own tools, usually in pursuit of food.
I've never seen a single crow take a bird on the wing and usually when crows arrive at a feeder the smaller birds scatter. It is something I've never heard of. But for a single crow or group of crows to come up with a new strategy or behaviour is not unusual eihter. There can be a whole list of reasons, maybe a sick or aberrant crow doing something of no obvious value, maybe over zealous nest guarding, maybe for food (whop them on the head and then drop down a little while later when they stop moving) and maybe what you saw was not really what you saw, if you catch my drift.
How could a crow do this? The one strategy comes to mind--and it doesn't fit with nest protection--would be to sit quietly within the branches of a tree near to a feeder and let the other birds become very accusatomed to it. As a group of birds flock in and out it would be possible in time that one bird would get close enough and whap! Afterward supper. (See too Tyra's second post, with a similar stratey on the ground, which came in as I was just about to send).
Even if the crow didn't eat it right away, if they eat porcuypine there's no reason to think it couldn't eat something smaller. It's the circle of life.
If you're 100% on what you're rightly seewing and crows are frequenting the spot you might try seldom removing the feeder for a week or 10 days. But admire the crow too. They are really remarkable creatures.
Popular posts by chadnibal
Hairy Woodpecker?
Hummingbird Feed
Amusing Crow Behaviour
|
|
|
| | | post reply |
nedwards
User
Junior Member
| Posts: 35 | |
Karma: 0
|
re:Why do crows kill sparrows? - 2006/05/10 18:14
Are you sure the crow was killin the spasrrow, not just surely toying with an allready dead or injured bird? I'd not expect a crow to be able to catch a sparow.
Popular posts by nedwards
Peculiar birds in my yard
juveniles
A conversation on conservation
|
|
|
| | | post reply |
dmbmystery
User
Newbie
| Posts: 5 | |
Karma: 0
|
re:Why do crows kill sparrows? - 2006/05/11 12:39
Jack
Popular posts by dmbmystery
Hummingbird Moth
Is this a hummingbird?
KAMIKAZE SEAGULLS!!!!!!!!!
|
|
|
| | | post reply |
jeeps_mom
User
Junior Member
| Posts: 21 | |
Karma: 0
|
re:Why do crows kill sparrows? - 2006/05/12 13:35
It realy do not even need to do this- you know how songbirds mob & chase crows when they're nest-immediately robbing? They fly close and nip at the back? Lately maybe the bigger bird sometyimes grabs one of the songbirds.
Popular posts by jeeps_mom
grosbeak mia
Warbler ID
Loons
|
|
|
| | | post reply |
Sundance
User
Junior Member
| Posts: 16 | |
Karma: 0
|
re:Why do crows kill sparrows? - 2007/06/01 04:06
I raised a baby crow.
Popular posts by Sundance
baby bird
Stranded Baby Bird! - URGENT!
URGENT help with a baby bird nee...
|
|
|
| | | post reply |
Sundance
User
Junior Member
| Posts: 16 | |
Karma: 0
|
re:Why do crows kill sparrows? - 2007/06/01 04:15
Her name is Hosa
I taught her how to find food and use eggs! I taught her to kill hen chicks.
I mean chickens.
By using eggs, it was I would give her eggs and she would feed them to her chicks.
She once followed my son, from our house to town. He was doing a paper delievery. He was 5 miles from our house, but there she was!
She said, Hello! to him .
Crows, they are really cool birds and how many sparrows are there, really?
Popular posts by Sundance
baby bird
Stranded Baby Bird! - URGENT!
URGENT help with a baby bird nee...
|
|
|
| | | post reply |
Sundance
User
Junior Member
| Posts: 16 | |
Karma: 0
|
re:Why do crows kill sparrows? - 2007/06/01 04:18
Geez! The other thing I do is have a Raven feeder, like a bird feeder.
Popular posts by Sundance
baby bird
Stranded Baby Bird! - URGENT!
URGENT help with a baby bird nee...
|
|
|
| | | post reply |
aloha
Admin
Admin
| Posts: 723 | |
Karma: 5
|
re:Why do crows kill sparrows? - 2007/06/01 21:55
In my city crows have attacked over 100 people. Mostly because they (by accident) came to close to their chicks, or.. tried to 'rescue' them after they'd fallen out of the nest and no mother-crow was in sight. The crow would come from afar and attack and keep on attacking. Even when the little one was placed back, the crow would still attack the person. This happened to 100 (separate) people in my little town...
To be honest: I don't like crows at all.
Popular posts by aloha
What is this bird?
Egret & friends - for Robert :)...
probably a kingfisher
|
|
|
| | | post reply |
monkey123
User
Newbie
| Posts: 2 | |
Karma: 0
|
re:Why do crows kill sparrows? - 2008/05/13 04:31
Today I actually did see a crow with a live sparrow in its beak, flying from tree limb to telephone line, to tree limb (etc) while three other sparrows pursued the crow. The pursuing sparrows were making frantic cries, and then the crow just flew off with the captured sparrow, with the three other sparrows in an ineffectual pursuit.
|
|
|
| | | post reply |
aloha
Admin
Admin
| Posts: 723 | |
Karma: 5
|
re:Why do crows kill sparrows? - 2008/05/13 07:31
Hi Monkey123 welcome to the forum. I hope you will like it here 
I h-a-t-e crows and these stories don't make me feel any kinder towards them. I know it is animal instinct and all that -but I find them very cruel looking birds.
Popular posts by aloha
What is this bird?
Egret & friends - for Robert :)...
probably a kingfisher
|
|
|
| | | post reply |
rosemont
User
Newbie
| Posts: 1 | |
Karma: 0
|
Re:Why do crows kill sparrows? - 2008/06/01 20:46
I just witnessed a sparrow was captured and then killed by a crow. The crow is big, though the sparrow is not a small one. There were a big flock of sparrows around all the time. For a couple of times, the sparrow was able to get away and tried to fly off. It never got more than a few feet though.
It's an impressive scene, that drew my attention when I was driving passing by. On the other hand, the crow looks so cold blooded. It was so calm!
|
|
|
| | | post reply |
aloha
Admin
Admin
| Posts: 723 | |
Karma: 5
|
Re:Why do crows kill sparrows? - 2008/06/02 10:09
I see crows chasing other birds all the time. I really hate that sight. It is that I am a peaceful person but else I would be throwing stones at them. I don't understand that they aren't controlled by the municipalities since they seem to be taking over more and more areas from other animals (like lizards as well). Grrrr.
Popular posts by aloha
What is this bird?
Egret & friends - for Robert :)...
probably a kingfisher
|
|
|
| | | post reply |
krst
User
Newbie
| Posts: 1 | |
Karma: 0
|
Re:Why do crows kill sparrows? - 2008/08/13 02:12
Okay what luck to come across this....this is what I witnessed today on a walk. A crow and sparrow were jumping at each other on the sidewalk, the crow then grabbed the sparrow with its beak and flew off into a tree with the sparrow flapping around in its grasp. During all this, other crows were making noise in the trees and when the killer crow landed in the tree with the bird a few crows flew over too. And then out of nowhere a Broad-winged hawk flew into the tree and all the crows scattered. The hawk then sat on the porch of a house and ate the sparrow. It all was very interesting to watch.
|
|
|
| | | post reply |
vishal
User
Newbie
| Posts: 1 | |
Karma: 0
|
Re:Why do crows kill sparrows? - 2008/12/09 15:40
[i] i am too unhappy due to the same reason...
and yes i to hav somewat same story wit me but its all close to me..
a sparrow gave birth to two cute small sparrows in my balcony at the corner in a small wooden cupboard.
there mother had died acidentally in my house due to fan...
since then father of tat two sparrows used to serve them,i identified him as father from spot under his neck supposing him to b of male gender...he everyday used to feed them both..and let me tell u it takes long time for them to grow and fly.
after some days one sparrow was not there,dont know where it gone..but one was still there,it came out of cupboard down on floor
it daily used to sleep in the corner of the floor,everyday its father used to feed him.even i used to give it some rice to eat..it had bcome to friendly to us all,it was not at all afraid of us i used to go too close to it but it didnt use to run away 4rm us
after long days i noticed tat a crow entered in opur balcony and tried to hit the sparrow,but couldnt get it,i ran in to the balcony and the crow ran away,then i started keeping eye onit to proctect it and was waiting for it to fly one day..
after some days it started alittle to fly above upto 1 feet above the ground...when the crow used to come it then started coming inside the house,so i bcame a little free tat it can protect itself.
but one day i and my mom slept,we had closed the curtains to avoid sunlight,after sometime there was lot of noise of crow,
i went out in balcony and found tat the sparrow wasnt there,i saw on the tree in front and found tat the crow was hitting him badly...
and ya many crows arrived there and started shouting,the crow holded it in its beak and took him away from there...
i tried a lot to make them away but couldn't...
i had lost one of my best friend ever,i cried a lot tat night for my friend...but couldnt help..
since then a HATE THE CROWS A LOTTTT.........
it took away my friend from me...
i hate hate hate hate the crows a lot lot lotlot
|
|
|
| | | post reply |
jennismortal
User
Newbie
| Posts: 7 | |
Karma: 0
|
Re:Why do crows kill sparrows? - 2009/06/05 11:12
I think..A crow and sparrow were jumping at each other on the sidewalk, the crow then grabbed the sparrow with its beak and flew off into a tree with the sparrow flapping around in its grasp. During all this, other crows were making noise in the trees and when the killer crow landed in the tree with the bird a few crows flew over too. And then out of nowhere a Broad-winged hawk flew into the tree and all the crows scattered.
---------
Good source for fish tank aquariums
Popular posts by jennismortal
Who is this bird?
Good idea
Hi everyone
|
|
|
| | | post reply |
|
post new topic